[CppCodeGen] Managed Exception Dispatch and Unwind

static void Main() {
     try {
          throw new Exception();
    }
    catch {
          Console.WriteLine("Exception caught");
    }
}

@jkotas

@jkotas I have setup corert on my local machine. I compiled this with using RyuJIT and then CPP Code Generator. Both worked and caught the exception. Could you please let me know a bit more about the issue here?

I suspect that you are not actually running the code using CoreRT - exception handling does not work yet with either RyuJIT or CppCodeGen.

Try following steps in Documentation\how-to-build-and-run-ilcompiler-in-visual-studio-2015.md or Documentation\how-to-build-and-run-ilcompiler-in-console-shell-prompt.md. The Visual Studio steps are more convenient for day to day development, just change the repro project to throw and catch exception to see the crash when you run the program.

The plan should be:

Piggy back on C++ exception handling
Use explicit checks instead of hardware exceptions (e.g. explicit checks for null reference exceptions)

Unity IP2CPP internals blog shows example of possible way to do this. Mono LLVM pure bitcode backend has same problem and it uses similar scheme to solve it.

@jkotas

@jkotas
Relying on C++ Exception handling seems sub optimal, while it would solve stack walking for exceptions, there are overheads to using C++ Exception handling and none of the other uses of stack walking (GC and StackTrace) would be able to leverage that overhead.

I've been reading the Book of the Runtime section on stack walking and from what I can tell, in the JITed version, stack walking is implemented using a mapping of instruction pointer ranges to function definition metadata. Allowing the stack walker to unwind each frame by doing a lookup and then moving the stack pointer backwards (based on the size specified in the looked up metadata), repeatedly until it gets where it wants to.

This seems like the most performant solution to the problem, but while its possible to get the address of a function in C++, I don't see a (portable) way to get the address of the last instruction in a function. Is RIP mapping really a dead end or is there some kind of sentinel stack cookie way I'm overlooking.

Portability is primary goal for CppCodeGen, performance is secondary. I think the C++ exception handling is the best we can do without compromising portability.

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

[CppCodeGen] Managed Exception Dispatch and Unwind #910

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

[CppCodeGen] Managed Exception Dispatch and Unwind #910

Description

Activity

AlexBHarley commented on Feb 21, 2016

jkotas commented on Feb 21, 2016

jkotas commented on Jan 21, 2017

hippiehunter commented on Sep 16, 2017

jkotas commented on Sep 16, 2017

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions